By Marc S. Sanders
Once again the man in blue, red and yellow has returned to the big screen by means of director James Gunn who is intent on starting a whole new universe of DC comics characters. The 2025 interpretation of Superman is zippy and fun even if it is a little too shallow of character development and dimension. That’s regrettably ironic actually. A man who dons two different personalities, Superman and mild-mannered reporter Clark Kent. Yet, neither has much to say or stand for in this two hour picture.
Gunn’s film is defiant to avoid any heavy exposition as this film begins. There’s a slim foreword as the picture begins to describe this new universe that contains metahumans who arrived on Earth centuries ago, along with a little bit of Kal-el’s origin that many of us are familiar with. Then we see the Man Of Steel crater into the Antarctic wounded from battle and aided by his feisty canine friend, Krypto, who drags him to his ice palace, the Fortress of Solitude.
Action commences thereafter back in Metropolis. Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult) is pulling the puppet strings. Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) and the rest of the Daily Planet staff witness the mayhem over the city.
Then we get a bit of Clark looking a little goofy as he rushes into work, followed by some romantic interlude between Clark and Lois back at her apartment. The two toe the line of their relationship when finally, the Superman persona allows his girlfriend to test his purpose for serving planet Earth along with his limits of authority and decisive action. They go back and forth but none of the dialogue lands and the argument has no impact. A missed opportunity to set up the Lois and Clark relationship.
The rest of the picture focuses on comic book episodes of endangering Superman while other metahumans make appearances – an obnoxious Green Lantern (Nathan Fillion), Hawkgirl, the shape shifting Metamorpho, and the surprisingly entertaining Mr. Terrific (Edi Gathegi) who seems to operate like Mr. Spock from Star Trek. Of the four, the guy with the dumbest name actually serves the picture the best.
James Gunn’s film takes a huge departure from the recent films of Zach Snyder’s universe. Nothing is dark and hardly anything is morose. Some subplots seem to be ripped from the headlines of current events that’ll have you thinking about the Russian-Ukraine war. None of it is overly heavy though because this picture is designed for families to watch together.
Superman is pure escape with a red cape.
What I miss though is what both the Snyder and the Christopher Reeve pictures offered. What does Superman mean to himself and the planet Earth? The one conversation between Lois and Clark/Superman goes on long and while it feels like there is a purpose in that exchange, I cannot recall one kind of conclusion that stemmed from it. For the rest of the film, Lois flies a spaceship and helps a weakened Superman find aid. When the two share any more scenes together it is for the action of the piece followed by a kissing scene. I just didn’t respond to the puppy love or risks of their relationship that other iterations offered. Their connection is just written a little too thin. That’s a problem, because the Superman mythos always hinged on their relationship in the face of danger or true love or even journalistic integrity.
Am I being too serious and hardheaded? Yes. Nevertheless, even with a comic book/Saturday morning cartoon gloss, I wanted to see more weight to the relationship between the two characters.
The best attraction is Nicholas Hoult as a connivingly evil Lex Luthor. He’s a raging madman bent on destroying Superman like everyone knows and the actor chews the scenery while primarily hiding in his glass headquartered command center for most of the film. Anytime the movie diverts to Luthor, the picture just felt more alive. This is a great Lex Luthor!!!!!!
Like he did with a smart aleck racoon in his other films, James Gunn introduces a toy line merchandise with the flying white terrier dog known as Krypto. His intent is for audiences to cheer for him like other precocious creatures from past films such as any Disney movie or E.T. or Baby Yoda or Rocket Raccoon. He’s cute and spirited. When he’s in danger, the kids will be worried. When he flies into the center of the screen with a bark or a yelp, everyone will applaud.
David Corenswet is Superman. He’s fine. He definitely looks like the part. He’s a happy go lucky Kryptonian. He’ll never be as memorable as Christopher Reeve. I also have more to appreciate in Henry Cavill’s performance. I just didn’t see Corenswet do enough with this role. I’ve yet to really see the dramatic chops he could offer. Simply lying on the floor of a cell while falling ill to Krytonite is not urgent or frightening enough. I hardly got to know this guy to care enough if he lives or dies. I hope he’ll blossom some more within future installments of Gunn’s superhero universe. That’s up to the writers though. David Corenswet is pleasingly relaxed in a role that demands almost a hundred years of acceptance for a modern age. I’m confident he can do it and that Gunn cast the right guy for the part. While he’s acceptable, both Corenswet and Brosnahan would best be served better material for them to work together.
As for Rachel Brosnahan, I guess she’s okay. I don’t see her do much beside fly a spaceship. Lois Lane is such an immense character of brains and gusto striving to always be the number one reporter. Her only weakness is her love for Superman. There’s not much I remember about her from this film. I did notice that she primarily wears purple like the character did in 1990’s animated series. Nice salute. Come on James Gunn. Rachel Brosnahan is good actress. Give her something more to do. Let her act a little. (Let David Corenswet act a little too.)
It’s wonderful that an optimistic interpretation of Superman has arrived. We need it. It’s colorful and fun. It could be more exciting, though, with higher stakes that just didn’t arrive quite right. This film is not my ideal picture of the hero, but the universe to come, especially with a quick appearance from another character at the conclusion, offers promise.
Despite my reservations, the new DC Cinematic Universe seems to be in the right hands once again, and James Gunn’s team will deliver something entertaining for the next few years to come.
2 UNPAID MOVIE CRITICS!!!! 