By Marc S. Sanders
Ryan Coogler is one of the most inventive writer/directors working today. This is a filmmaker who will assemble a hundred different ideas into one body of work. All of it makes sense when blended together. A movie musical sourced in blues and grassroots instruments like banjo, piano, harmonica, foot stomping and guitar stitched together on to a horror film? Once the wheels get turning, Coogler can’t see it any other way and so he lands upon October 15, 1932, one day and one very long night in Clarksdale, Mississippi where Sinners takes place.
The smokestack twins – Smoke and his brother Stack – return from working with Al Capone in Chicago. They’ve got lots of money and big plans to open up the Juke Joint when the sun sets. Michael B Jordan plays the charming gentlemen. Smoke is donned in blue accents, while his brother Stack is identified primarily in red. Jordan is such a skilled and aggressive actor in everything he does. I truly did not realize he was playing both roles until about a third of the way through the picture. His performances are so tantalizingly unique and memorable that Jordan has to be a contender for an Oscar nomination.
The boys circumvent the Clarksdale area. First they purchase a barn and the land it dwells upon. With their pistols at the ready, their purchasing agreement is that the seller’s Klan associates do not come around here. They go to the train station to recruit Delta Slim (Delroy Lindo) for the piano and harmonica. Smoke visits Ruthie (Andrene Ward-Hammond) to prepare the most delicious crawfish and shrimp. Ruthie is also the mother of Smoke’s deceased infant child and they need to catch up on some history that was not tied off. Stack needs to contend with Mary (Hailee Steinfeld), his sultry lover from the past who was also left behind unexpectedly.
Most impressive is a debut performance from Miles Caton as Sammie Moore, the local preacher’s son, and the kid who can strum a mean guitar in the back seat of a car or down at the joint. Sammie looks up to the twins. They will show him how to carry himself. There’s a history to everyone the men encounter. Sometimes they are welcome. Sometimes they’re not, like the Klan, and sometimes they’d rather avoid who they come across as they continue to spread the word about the Juke Joint celebration that’s too come with all the liquor, food, and music they can imagine.
Michael B Jordan and Miles Caton are definitely Oscar worthy; two very hot properties. Caton can do it all. He can sing and act. He’s as big a surprise as Mikey Madison was with Anora. You can’t take your eyes off of him and if the guy goes on tour, I’m buying a ticket to see him.
A prologue narration followed by a disturbing, eye-opening epilogue scene within a town church opens Sinners. Something unfathomable must have happened at the Juke Joint on this particular night.
I went into this film having not seen a trailer, a commercial or even reading an article about it. I was not aware of the blazing bluegrass root music that populates this film, nor of the surprise monster fest that eventually takes overtakes the story. It was a better viewing experience for me than I imagine had I known some of the details of Coogler’s film. This gorgeous film accompanied by magnificent sound and visual details with award caliber editing and direction steers into so many different curveball surprises and genres. Sinners is a film that you go see in the movie theater. The Juke Joint alone is worth the price of admission. As memorable a setting as Rick’s Place in Casablanca, the Cantina in Star Wars or Jack Rabbit Slim’s in Pulp Fiction.
You read it here first! The Juke Joint is sure to be a haunted house at Universal’s Halloween Horror Nights. I promise you.
That being said, my love for the two-and-a-half-hour film dwindled during its last third when the monsters are revealed and the picture spirals into a blood fest battle between heroes and villains with spurting blood, fiery Molotov cocktails, guns and screaming and wrestling and chases upstairs and out the doors and off the balconies. I’ve seen all of this a hundred times before and as well constructed as a film this is, nothing was surprising me anymore. Nothing was giving me jump scares.
For such an imaginative picture, the inventions went into neutral. The dialogue starts to drain in lieu of schlock gore and the intelligence of this abundance of characters checks out at the door. Some of what you see looks like material that could have been in Friday The 13th Part 14. And, well, a lot of the material is a rehash of Robert Rodriguez and Quentin Tarantino’s very proud B movie From Dusk Til Dawn.
Until the final act of Sinners, Ryan Coogler incorporates so much researched and genuine attention into this Jim Crow era film. I read that while he was making the Creed and Black Panther films, he was feeling withdrawn after a favorite uncle passed away. This uncle told stories of this Mississippi area, complete with a small immigration of Chinese populace. Coogler capitalized on that idea and a well-drawn couple named Bo and Lisa Chow (Yao, Helena Hu) are weaved into this story to supply food and drink for the party that’s to come. No one would ever question if these two were not part of this cast. They could have been two black actors or even a pair of whites, but Coogler ensures additional flavors are worked into the film with the authenticity to back it. These are not even walk on roles. They own two different mercantile stores within the heart of town.
The best idea to Sinners is when the music is most entertaining at the Juke. Ryan Coogler has fun with the clay he infinitely molds. A long Steadicam shot is the centerpiece of the film as it travels through the whole barn that has been transformed into the Joint. Coogler seamlessly goes for an ethereal or maybe spiritual feel as the sweaty, sexy and rhythmic performers and their music blends into all kinds of jazz, rap and soul found within the future generations of this community. A turntable scratcher is positioned next to an acoustic guitar player or a banjo, and as deliberately anachronistic as this seems for 1932, it all belongs together within this seasoned stew.
Outside the Juke Joint are the monsters priming for their own celebration to come with Celtic harmonies, clogging and river dancing to get their appetites drooling, literally drooling. Two communities will clash and it will be for more than just than standard prejudices found along the cotton fields of Jim Crow Mississippi.
This was not an easy review to write. I do not want to disclose the surprises and turns that Sinners takes. As well, my experience with the film is a mixed bag. There is so much new and fresh material found in Ryan Coogler’s picture, but there’s also a lot of staple work that’s all too familiar as well. What I recognize is not the least bit surprising and it is frankly uninteresting to me. Sinners needed the creation of a new kind of cinematic monster to uphold its inventions.
Especially considering that the body horror film The Substance and Jordan Peele’s terrifyingly smart Get Out earned tons of accolades recently, it will not be a surprise if Sinners earns a lot of end-of-the-year nominations as well. The direction, editing, art design and costume design are equally worthy of large appreciation. Sinners has likely clinched a spot for Best Picture nomination. Only the wrap up will deny itself of the trophy though.
I must end with a long overdue BRAVO to horror. Often the genre does not get deserved recognition, because so much of it runs on cheap gross out junk or jump scares with no sensible reasoning behind any of it. Guys like Coogler and Peele are finally working on the braininess which can be found in this area of storytelling and craftmanship. They know there are scarier things to imagine than a foreboding hockey mask.
2 UNPAID MOVIE CRITICS!!!! 