By Marc S. Sanders
In the late 1980s a novel idea hit the screens. An MTV interpretation of the Old West with a rock anthem soundtrack of electric guitars and drums. A far separation from Ennio Morricone’s unbeatable spaghetti western approach.
The film was Young Guns, featuring handsome stars like Emilio Estevez, Kiefer Sutherland, and Lou Diamond Phillips. They were each different kind of gunslingers in their own right while delivering stand out personalities. The film has some problems in editing, and some sequences do not work. Yet, it remains stylish with impressive set designs, props, costume wear, and an especially appealing array of performances from the whole cast.
Billy The Kid aka William H Bonney is one of the most notorious outlaws in American history. Emilio Estevez brilliantly turns the gunslinger into a quick draw joker with an addictive cackle and an adorable smile. William is taken in by the mentoring John Tunstall (Terence Stamp) who already oversees a collection of orphaned young men. He’s teaching them to bear responsibility on his farm while they learn proper manners at the dinner table and how to read.
A neighboring industrial enemy, L.G. Murphy (Jack Palance) commissions his men to gun down Tunstall. Billy and the rest of the gang are then deputized by the local Sheriff to issue warrants for the arrest of the killers. However, Billy repeatedly exercises his own form of justice by killing one guy after another with his pair of six shooters. Soon after, the boys are on the run by horseback while creating a whole bunch of mayhem.
I never considered Young Guns to be a perfect film, but I like it a whole heck of a lot.
There are moments that serve no purpose, like when the men get high on peyote, introduced by the Navajo, Chavez Y Chavez (Lou Diamond Phillips). It’s not amusing. It’s not quotable and the scene runs too long as we watch the cast walk and talk while in daze. Frankly, most movie scenes of just watching people get high are boring. Often, they go nowhere and I’m not sure how to respond. It’s like I’m the designated driver fiddling with my car keys at a drunken binge fest. This is no different.
As well, there seem to be gaps within the body of the story. I know it is inspired by the Lincoln County War, but it’s never entirely clear why Tunstall and Murphy are at odds with each other. We just have to accept that the two elderly men of equal proportions are against one another. Still, Palance versus Stamp is a very inviting conflict to look at. (Supposedly, the real John Tunstall was only in his mid-20s.)
Young Guns has a very cool polish. These cowboys are downright attractive, sexy like Hollywood movies tend to offer, and I love how they handle each other, their horses and their pistols. Every time a six shooter whips out of a holster and clicks, the movie becomes more alive. The guys look well-worn within this environment, close to the Mexican border of the 1870s. The image is just as effective as Clint Eastwood appears in his various assortment of westerns.
Billy The Kid, over this film and its sequel, is Emilio Estevez’ best role of his career. The actor has such a cocky, nervy way about him and his over-the-top laugh is impossible to forget. A favorite scene in all of movies emerges when Billy toys with a bounty hunter in a saloon. Estevez delivers much fun before gunning the guy down. I never tire of watching that moment.
Kiefer Sutherland is second in line with a graceful sensitivity as the educated and poetically romantic Doc Scurlock. You worry about him and his courting affair with a young Chinese concubine that is owned by Murphy. Lou Diamond Phillips specializes in knife throwing as Chavez, the token Navajo. His presence belongs here as an unpredictable sidekick.
The best surprise is delivered by Casey Siemaszko as the virginal, boyish illiterate Charlie. Some gunslingers were afraid to ever become outlaws. Charlie is ugly and dirty, bumbling and sweet, reminiscent of Fredo in The Godfather films. Siemaszko never became as established as the others in the cast, but he’s a good performer who delivers panicked fear and brings the glamour of Young Guns down to a semblance of reality.
Young Guns is a style over substance product. It has potential for a stronger storyline, but the dialogue works and the cast is stellar, which also includes Dermot Mulroney, Terry O’Quinn and Charlie Sheen. The sequel is actually better as it commits closer to the intrigue of Billy The Kid.
Not perfect, but this is a fun escapist western experience.
