by Miguel E. Rodriguez
DIRECTOR: John Huston
CAST: Sterling Hayden, Louis Calhern, Jean Hagen, James Whitmore, Sam Jaffe, Marilyn Monroe
MY RATING: 8/10
ROTTEN TOMATOMETER: 97% Fresh
PLOT: A major heist goes off as planned (almost), but then double crosses, bad luck, and solid police work cause everything to unravel.
On the Criterion Blu Ray of John Huston’s The Asphalt Jungle, noir historian Eddie Muller says you can draw a straight line from Jungle to the French heist film Rififi on through to the Tom Cruise Mission: Impossible franchise and Three Kings. To that list I would add the crime films of David Mamet. At the moment, I can’t think of another movie in Asphalt Jungle’s era in which the dialogue is so flat, menacing, and uncluttered. The story is exciting without being flashy, the characters are sharply drawn, and the cinematography creates the underbelly of a city almost Blade Runner-ish in its gloom. Even the planned jewelry heist, while detailed, is almost like a Hitchcock MacGuffin: the heist itself hardly matters, only the results…like Reservoir Dogs. Another descendant.
Doc Erwin Riedenschneider (Sam Jaffe) has just gotten out of prison. After evading a police tail, he visits a local clip joint looking for help in putting together a heist he had worked on before he was imprisoned. (I like how Doc and his colleagues rarely refer to “jail” or “prison”; it’s always “behind the walls.”) He eventually enlists Gus, the wheel man (James Whitmore); Louis, the safecracker (Anthony Caruso); and Dix Handley, the muscle (Sterling Hayden, as shambling as ever, even in 1950). Doc dismisses Handley as a hooligan. “Violence is all they know, but they are, unfortunately, necessary.” Throughout the film, Handley will do nothing to prove them wrong.
They need a bankroll for the heist, so the team goes to a crooked lawyer, Alonzo Emmerich (Louis Calhern), who agrees to their terms, but eventually reveals himself to be even more crooked than they are. (Emmerich has a mistress, Angela, played by a young, gorgeous Marilyn Monroe in the role that made her a star. She calls Alonzo “Uncle Lon” and steals every scene she’s in. John Huston reportedly said Monroe was “one of the few actresses who could make an entrance by leaving the room.”)
The Asphalt Jungle is not so much about the heist as it is about the characters and their behaviors. We watch how Dix Handley treats the one woman in his life, the appropriately named Doll (Jean Hagen). She shows up on his doorstep the day after he’s released from a police lineup. He grudgingly acknowledges her existence and allows her to crash at his place for a couple of nights, “but don’t you go getting any ideas, Doll.” We see the money man, Emmerich, as he sweats about his planned double-cross, but still has to find the time to placate his bedridden wife. There’s a great scene with Gus, the wheel man, who also owns a greasy spoon. A rude cabbie takes cruel jabs at Gus’s hunched back, crippled gait, and scrawny pet cat; Gus reveals his true colors when he handily throws the cabby out of his restaurant while Dix looks on, amused.
Everyone gets their character-driven spotlight, even a crooked cop, Lt. Ditrich, who is assigned the task of finding Doc Riedenschneider, but when he does see him inside a clip joint, he simply turns around and walks away. Later, Ditrich has a brutal scene with the weak-willed owner of the clip joint where he slaps him around several times to get him to spill his guts. Watch the scene carefully, and it certainly looks as if Ditrich is really slapping this guy around.
Behavior is everything in this movie, not necessarily the plot. Without giving too much away, behavior is what gets two characters killed, gets one arrested, drives another to suicide, and leads one to meet his fate in a horse pasture. Nothing feels artificial or melodramatic. There is an inevitability to what happens, a tragic undercurrent, that causes us to empathize with these hardened criminals. These are not nice people. But when one character unwisely stays seated in a diner when he really should have left, we are disappointed. When one character’s lies to the police come back to haunt him, we shake our heads in resignation. Their nature got the best of them.
Sterling Hayden is the headliner of The Asphalt Jungle, and he does get one or two scenes that are “juicier” than the rest, but this is a true ensemble piece. It takes its time to make us familiar with each key player, with who they are, so we will understand why they do what they do at every turn. That may seem like Storytelling 101, but you’d be surprised how many movies get that wrong. Here’s one that gets it right in spades.
