By Marc S. Sanders
Bill Murray with director Richard Donner delivered their contribution to the Charles Dickens assortment of A Christmas Carol iterations with a modern update called Scrooged. Until now, this movie eluded me. Yet I can’t deny it has all the ingredients for a sure-fire green light to make the movie. Bill Murray? Doing Ebenezer Scrooge? Stop everything people! Get this ready for December. STAT!
Unfortunately, it misses the mark.
Now, I’m supposed to like this miser by the end of the story, right? So then why is Murray’s personification so annoying and unappealing by the end? If I was his nephew, I’d rescind my invitation to come over for Christmas dinner.
The best and most hilarious part of Scrooged occurs in the beginning following the easily recognizable Danny Elfman instrumentals. Santa and his elves are happily making toys when suddenly terrorists attack the North Pole and Lee Majors jumps out of nowhere ready to bear arms with ol’ St. Nick and his crew. I was sad to realize this was only a TV commercial for the station programming that Murray’s character oversees. If there is a God, he’ll reveal the location of the lost film for The Night The Reindeer Died. Earlier this year I saw Lee Majors needlessly squandered away in the terrible Fall Guy adaptation. It crushes me that he got this same kind of treatment over thirty years prior.
Bill Murray is the uncaring and thoughtless Frank Cross. When we meet him on Christmas Eve day, he’s firing an executive (Bobcat Goldthwaite) for simply disagreeing with him. Also, in typical overplayed Bill Murray fashion, Frank insists that his assistant Grace (Alfre Woodard) ignore the needs of her family during the holiday and get work done with him. Grace of course filling in for the Bob Cratchit role.
Following a few other gags to parade the comedian’s antics around, Frank is encountered with the Jacob Marley stand in, played by John Forsythe. At this point I’m still with the picture even if the breadcrumbs are easy to follow. Forsythe, in his grotesque makeup, works well against the clown who leads this movie. (Not a bad scene together between Charlie and Bosley. “Hello Angels!”).
It’s when the follow up ghosts make appearances that my mind ponders what I’ll be writing about in this review. Ghosts of Christmas Past (David Johansen) and Present (Carol Kane) enter on cue and right away I grew bored and uninterested.
Johansen is a cabbie, or just another screeching screamer like Murray. He’s laughing at Frank’s demise and past missed opportunities, but I’m not seeing what’s funny or even heartbreaking. Neither theatrical mask of comedy or tragedy is functioning. Carol Kane does her typical schtick with the high-pitched baby talk voice, dressed in a fairy get up. Beyond that familiar routine, she commits every kind of Three Stooges smack and painful tug on Frank’s face that you can imagine. Why of all things does she rely on a toaster to upper cut the jerk in his face? I mean why a toaster???? If the comedy works, then I should not be wondering why a toaster or a pie or two by four or an anvil.
There’s nothing wisely written here. The screaming and the smacking get old very fast and it gets in the way of a potential love story passed by that the script was promising for the Frank Cross character and his crush Claire (Karen Allen, whose smile always lights up a room). I never felt like Bill Murray was ever listening to Karen Allen in the scenes they share. Did they even rehearse this stuff? Too often, Bill Murray seems to just be winging it, and it wouldn’t make a difference if Karen Allen even memorized her lines.
Scrooged starts out with fresh, quality made National Lampoon material but then waddles into the same typical chapters of Dickens’ holiday story. However, while it hammers the familiar story beat by beat and you tell yourself there’s the Fred character and there’s the mute kid covering for a crippled Tiny Tim and there’s Yet To Come, you got Bill Murray who was granted too much artistic license to improvise, and has thus squeezed out all of the sensitivity and spirit that we expect from A Christmas Carol.
I’m sorry but I think I liked this Frank Cross a whole lot more before he was visited by the ghosts. This is one Scrooge who should’ve been allowed to sleep through Christmas.
PS: If anyone can find a DVD print of The Night The Reindeer Died, I’m ready to review it.
