By Marc S. Sanders
Al Pacino is a twenty-year veteran New York City cop, working out of Manhattan, on the trail of a serial killer in Sea Of Love. The profession is nothing new to Pacino’s repertoire of roles, but the portrayal is unique thanks to a smart and suspenseful script from Richard Price and intense directing from Harold Becker.
The killer leaves a calling card. A 45 LP record of Phil Phillips ’50s classic crooner, “Sea Of Love,” spinning on the turntable. The victims are naked men lying face down in bed with a bullet to the head. Turns out that a cop from another precinct played by John Goodman has uncovered a similar crime scene in Queens. So, the two team up. They believe the murderer is a woman.
All the victims have posted a Lonely-Hearts Club blurb in a magazine. The invitation for a date stands out because the text rhymes. The detectives decide to post their own ad in the same kind of format, meet the women who respond and hope to nab the killer. It gets complicated when Pacino encounters a breathtaking and sultry woman played by Ellen Barkin.
Pacino’s cop is a smart guy. He’s got instincts. Yet, perhaps due to his constant drinking, insomnia, and the bitterness he carries now that his partner (Richard Jenkins) has hooked up with his ex-wife, he’s also quite vulnerable.
The mystery is strong, and the tension builds as Sea Of Love moves on. Barkin has Pacino and the audience convinced that she’s the prime suspect. Still, he lets his defenses down because he’s easily getting seduced by her advances.
Whether you’re watching Al Pacino share scenes with John Goodman or Ellen Barkin, the execution is fantastic. Great performances from the three. Pacino and Goodman have a natural exchange with one another. Often humorous, but the guys always talk like cops. When Pacino admits to tossing away a fingerprinted glass from Barkin, Goodman suggests lifting the prints from something- ahem – more personal of his. A cute wink and nod exchange.
More important to the film is the erotic chemistry between Barkin and Pacino. Harold Becker uses a late-night supermarket visit in the vegetable aisle to evoke the risky and irresistible nature the two characters develop for one another. Other scenes build well on the relationship between these two lonely strangers who’ve only recently met.
Moments of isolation and drunken stupors also work towards fleshing out Pacino’s burned out cop. He’s got a schleppy posture to him and an exhausted expression with his sullen eyes and shaggy black hair. At the same time, his character’s twenty years of experience seem to uphold his alertness. This cop knows he’s letting his guard down. Without any dialogue, you see the internal struggle Pacino has with what should be done against what he is deliberately neglecting.
This film was Ellen Barkin’s breakthrough role. She received rave reviews as someone who takes care to uphold a New York City trendy appearance by day as a shoe salesperson in contrast to a woman looking for some carefree lust in the evening. For Pacino, Sea Of Love reinvigorated a career slump following a series of poorly reviewed films. Together, they make for a sexy yet untrusting pair.
Circumventing this relationship is the mystery. Is Barkin the culprit? She seems to have a dark way about her that may not surprise you. Price, Barkin and Becker designed the character quite well for her to at least have the potential to be a killer of men. Is she setting Pacino up to be the next victim?
New York City from the late 1980s looks great, even though interiors were shot in Toronto. Trevor Jones offers a nail-biting soundtrack to keep the suspense heightened at just the right beats of the picture with Becker’s camera pointing down dark hallways or when new clues are discovered.
I’ve seen Sea Of Love a few times and even with knowing the surprise ending, the film still holds up thanks to the performances from its three stars, along with its taut editing, well-paced writing, and smart direction.
This is a good erotic murder mystery.
